Saturday, November 21 Late fall · second half of November Find your frost dates →

Frost Date Probabilities Explained: 10%, 50% and 90% Dates

What the 10%, 50% and 90% frost dates in NOAA normals mean, how to read spring and fall columns, and which date to use for each crop.

An average last frost date sounds like a promise, but it is closer to a coin flip. The 50% date means that in about half of past years a freeze came later. NOAA publishes the whole range, and reading it properly lets you match the risk to the crop.

What the NOAA numbers are

NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information publishes frost and freeze probability dates as a supplement to its Climate Normals. Dates are given at probability levels from 10% to 90% in steps of 10, for threshold temperatures that include 36°F, 32°F and 28°F, and the original release also covers 24, 20 and 16°F. NC State Extension notes that 36°F is the temperature NCEI’s tables associate with frost, while the lower thresholds describe freezes and hard freezes.

Reading the columns

In spring, the 10% date is the late one: only about one year in ten has a freeze after it. The 90% date is early, and a freeze after it is likely. The 50% date is the median. Fall flips this: the 10% date is the early one, with roughly a one in ten chance of a freeze before it.

A published example for Missoula, Montana at 32°F, from NOAA’s 1981-2010 normals:

  • Spring: 90% May 4, 50% May 18, 10% June 2
  • Fall: 10% September 11, 50% September 24, 90% October 5
  • Freeze-free season: 147 days at the 10% level, 128 at 50% and 106 at 90%

The 106-day figure is the season length you could count on in nine years out of ten. The 147-day figure happens about one year in ten.

Choosing a date for your crop

  • Tender crops: use a cautious date. Purdue Extension says very tender crops like cucumbers, eggplant, melons, okra, peppers, sweet potatoes and pumpkins should go in at least two weeks after the average last spring frost
  • Hardy crops: the 50% date or earlier works, with covers ready. See frost tolerance of vegetables
  • Fall crops: count back from the early fall date, not the median. The fall planting calculator does this
  • Crops that need a hard freeze to be sweet or that tolerate 28°F: use the 28°F column

Why your yard may differ

Normals describe a weather station, often an airport or town site, not your own backyard. Slopes, buildings and cold air pooling shift the real dates, as explained in garden microclimates. The Public Gardens Association also notes scientists are seeing frost and freeze dates and growing season lengths shift as the climate changes, so treat any table as a guide.

How GardenClock shows this

The planting calculators and city pages such as Chicago, New York and Columbus are built on NOAA station data and show a typical date and a later, cautious date. See data sources for exactly what we use, and how to use frost dates to turn them into a planting plan.

Sources

How to read a real probability table

NC State Extension explains that the National Centers for Environmental Information tables give dates at probability levels from 10 percent to 90 percent in steps of 10, and that the 10 percent and 90 percent levels suit risk-averse decisions. University of Massachusetts publishes the same kind of table for Connecticut. For Danbury, the 32°F spring dates are April 16, April 30 and May 15 at the three probability levels, and the 36°F dates are May 3, May 18 and June 1. The later dates are the lower-risk ones.

Frost versus freeze thresholds

The Danbury table shows why the threshold matters. A 36°F event is common later in spring than a 32°F one, so a source using 36°F will give a later last-frost date than one using 32°F. Check which threshold your source uses before comparing dates. Our frost vs freeze guide covers the terms.

A worked reading

University of Maryland Extension shows a Frederick, Maryland chart for the last 32°F: April 19 at the 10 percent level and March 29 at the 90 percent level. It describes April 19 as the lower-probability, safer planting date. The 50 percent date sits in between, close to April 9, and is what most tools label the average last frost.

Fall dates and the freeze-free period

The Danbury table gives fall 32°F dates of September 22, October 6 and October 20, and freeze-free periods of 179, 158 and 137 days. Pick the early fall date to protect a late crop and the late date to estimate how long you can keep harvesting. See how long your growing season is.

Choosing a level in practice

Use the 50 percent date for hardy crops, a later date for tender transplants, and a cover for anything in between. Our frost protection guide and the frost date lookup help you act on the number you choose.

More sources

Published by Sajib Saha, a web developer and SEO specialist. This guide is compiled from the extension and NOAA sources named above, not from personal horticultural credentials. See About and our editorial policy.